The Jedi Academy. THE Place for Jedi training.
Forums
Content
The Academy
Learn
Communicate
Personal


Forums | Star Wars Discussion
Luke vs Epi 3 Obi Wan
May 24 2005 03:01pm

Daral-zand
 - Student
Who do you think would win?


Poll
luke or obi wan

vote results

  Login and add your comment!  
Comments
Jun 01 2005 05:15pm

AndAgram
 - Ex-Student
 AndAgram

lukes like that big prophet guy but obi 1 0wnz0rd anikan and maul and he got shot at by clones (which i have just worked out are storm troopers! lol) and lukes got too long hair .. it could get burnt and thats the end of him, flames to his brain :) nice peaceful solution
(lighters solve everything :P
_______________
JOIN THE DARK SIDE!, we have cookies...
Don't have a lightsaber? How will you defend yourself against the Sith? Click here to select the model that's right for you.
if you strike me down, you'll lose your no claims bonus...


Jun 01 2005 08:36am

Future
 - Student
 Future

I think Luke win, because the force is really strong in him. :D
_______________
Trust your instincts.
Training partner Ma0s
Proud owner of: Ma0s 200th and 222th comment :)


May 29 2005 12:58pm

Kaden
 - Student

Obi-Wan of course...poor Luke :D
_______________
-- Use The Force --

May 29 2005 05:28am

skankerkid
 - Student
 skankerkid

yeah Obi-wan is the one for me
_______________
Shout out to DJ Sith cause he's my big bro. Shout out to Debbie because she's my sister in-law. Also it aint cool if aint skewed.

This comment was edited by skankerkid on May 29 2005 05:28am.

May 28 2005 11:52pm

Luke Skywalker
 - Student
 Luke Skywalker

Well.. you certainly don't come on much. >.>
_______________
:alliance:Luke Skywalker:alliance:

May 28 2005 11:41pm

Dacascos
 - Lowly Urchin
 Dacascos

Hey Lukeh. Just noticed you're still a student on your profile :P
_______________
PSN: Argantes
XBL: Ravencloak

My destiny lies where my fate leads me...


May 27 2005 11:43pm

Luke Skywalker
 - Student
 Luke Skywalker

I voted for myself... I am such a hypocrite. :P
_______________
:alliance:Luke Skywalker:alliance:

May 27 2005 07:18am

the_void
 - Student
 the_void

I'm gonna have to go with Obi on this one. Luke never had any formal training as a Jedi. only the mystic words from Ben in A New Hope and the makeshift training in the wilds of Dagobah from yoda. Neither were in the condition to formally train Luke to become the caliber Jedi they had once been. Even though Luke is the son of the "Chosen One" and may hold an advantage of controling the force more over Obi, he was still formally trained for a long long time, alot longer than luke and therefore i believe he would win.:D

May 26 2005 04:55pm

Gr1m
 - Student

I think luke would win, he has come to his senses in the force. I think it would depend which episode you are talking about.
_______________
Smokey, this isn't nam, this is bowling. There are rules.

May 26 2005 02:21am

Oolongo
 - Student
 Oolongo

I say Luke would win.
_______________
All hail the cute bunny!

May 25 2005 01:38pm

Daral-zand
 - Student

ok, i mean master luke in the Yuuzahn Vong period.now adding the poll part.

May 24 2005 10:02pm

Vasper Ba'xian
 - Student
 Vasper Ba'xian

Sorry but Luke would own him hands down!
_______________
Brother to: Tamal, Kavar, J.D.,Jermia, Devlin, Ulic, Xiabara, Seij,Tarron Mib,>>>ROCK ON:).My Spacescapes art page.My Everything Else art page. MY FAV. Jedi Are: Qui-Gon Jinn, Corran Horn, and Anakin Solo. Unofficial Master to Tamal. and Kavar. Founder of the Wuji Hundun Jian saber style. Proud owner of Tamal's 200th comment!//Proud owner of Refl3x's 300th comment!>>>Proud owner of Tyrant's 800th comment>>>Proud owner of Lucky's 170th comment>>>Proud owner of BDKawika's 444th comment>>>To except Existance is to except Reality.

May 24 2005 08:44pm

Lithaerien
 - Student
 Lithaerien

let's see...Our Jedi Master Luke? He'd own Obi any day ^.^
_______________
"The Dark Side? I've been there... Do your worst!" ~Kyle Katarn "Don't force it" ~GeForce

May 24 2005 08:37pm

Trad Redav
 - Student
 Trad Redav

Obi-Wan, even if you do mean Jedi Master Luke. Obi-Wan had an entire war to perfect his lightsaber skills, while Luke had... not much, unless you go into the Yuuzhan Vong stuff, but even with that the style of fighting would be so completely different it really wouldn't help him any.
_______________
Well then. Just so you know, just because I don't post often doesn't mean I don't lurk this place multiple times every day...

May 24 2005 07:39pm

Phantom
 - Student
 Phantom

Luke
_______________
-Phantom
Ex-Master to Threat.
Proud owner of Sazabi's 1500th comment! And Threats 50th comment
"Insanity: a perfect rational adjustment to an insane world"


May 24 2005 07:31pm

Carve
 - Student
 Carve

I don't really think that's a fair comparison. Yes, Luke is ridiculously strong in the Force, but he isn't even a Jedi Knight until the very end of RotJ. Jedi Knight with less than a year of training vs. Jedi Master with over 13 years of training... hmm. I wonder?

Now, Luke as a Jedi Master versus Episode III Obi-Wan is another matter entirely.
_______________
©

May 24 2005 07:27pm

NotSoLittleCaesar
 - Student
 NotSoLittleCaesar

rofl, obi by far, luke SUCKSSSS he never faught a strong opponent (apart from vader nad i mean..come on...he walked his fights..)
_______________
Quote:
I mostly agree oh Lord of the squeezy mop


May 24 2005 05:22pm

Raydoe_Mintaka
 - Student
 Raydoe_Mintaka

indeed hmmm Luke i would have to say cause he is the profecy but i don't think mark hamil is young enough to be a jedi anymore lol
_______________
There is no dominant stance of power. The Power is in the user....
Holder of Lucky-Adept 222th post and 92 Lucky Charm yay XD.Zadus 50th comment!Pink Floyd Mintaka700th comment
Rin_Mintaka 900th comment! ARGGGGGHHH MATEY!!!!!!!
Quote:
You are pretty tricky with red single heh :) Your style reminds me of 3th's :D ~R2D2


May 24 2005 04:06pm

Tyrant
 - Ex-Student
 Tyrant

It Depends...What Luke? Episode 4,5,6?

  Login and add your comment!