The Jedi Academy. THE Place for Jedi training.
Forums
Content
The Academy
Learn
Communicate
Personal


Forums | General Discussion
Who is better evanescence or nightwish
Oct 22 2003 03:01pm

sharwyn
 - ex-Student
Answer the g*d d*m question
And say why!
(btw vote evanescence, juts to prove sword master wrong yehehehe)

:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D

Poll
who is better evanescence or nightwish

vote results
Evanescence !!!!!!!! Evanescence !!!!!!!! [15 votes] [45%]
Nightwish (boooooooooo) Nightwish (boooooooooo) [8 votes] [24%]
who the hell is nightwish who the hell is nightwish [9 votes] [27%]
who the hell is Evanescence !!!!!!!! who the hell is Evanescence !!!!!!!! [1 vote] [3%]
both as good as each other!!!!!!!! both as good as each other!!!!!!!! [0 votes] [0%]

< Recent Comments Login and add your comment!  
Comments
Oct 24 2003 09:07pm

 
 - Student

Eh, no I wasn't, you're just stupid. :P

Besides, Evanescence are a CHRISTIAN band.

This comment was edited by   on Oct 24 2003 09:08pm.

Oct 24 2003 07:47pm

Drathir
 - Student
 Drathir

p00T both are okay!! 0000900909090
_______________
Where we ask the question, "Is real life really stranger than fiction, or is fiction about real life being stranger than fiction stranger than real life being stranger than fiction?" Ow.
-Paradox Lost
Want to read my slowly in progress webcomic?
-TCTI


Oct 24 2003 07:47pm

Drathir
 - Student
 Drathir

p00T both are okay!! 0000900909090
_______________
Where we ask the question, "Is real life really stranger than fiction, or is fiction about real life being stranger than fiction stranger than real life being stranger than fiction?" Ow.
-Paradox Lost
Want to read my slowly in progress webcomic?
-TCTI


Oct 24 2003 07:40pm

Hardwired
 - Retired
 Hardwired

I think CoB was being sarcastic......:)
_______________
::Nothing wrong with a little shooting.....as long as the right people get shot::

Oct 24 2003 02:53am

 
 - Student

Because Goth's are often aligned with satanism, masochism, and evilness.

I mean come on, the satanism thing is so metalhead. :P

Oct 24 2003 02:40am

MINDofSIN
 - Student
 MINDofSIN

Well Padawan, life isn't pretty. I like music that I can relate to. Some of it deals with death and suicide, some of it deals with religion.

I've been SIing(self injuring) for around two years, and it is something that, although I dislike doing it, is a signifigant part of my life. I have cut too deep a few times, and it's landed me in the hospital.

Despite my SI, I'm not suicidal. Those were very scary experiences for me and the song Tourniquet can bring tears to my eyes.

btw, why did you say "goth of course"?
_______________
Jedi Academy Holocron
http://jaholocron.ryanmh.com/

Why should our government send our soldiers to foreign soil to protect freedom of speech, when our freedom of speech is being taking away everyday by the same government.


Oct 24 2003 01:01am

Padawan On A Stick
 - Student
 Padawan On A Stick

who the hell is night wish??? i have no clue...

but ne wayz, i believe evanescence lyrics are based on suicide (goth of course) and drugs perhaps???, i mean c'mon, purple skies??? wats with that??? if there is symbolism, tell me bout it, but ne wayz.... they're ok.... BTW, tourniquet... something that contricts blood flow... no pretty pictures there....

nonetheless i really really really really really dislike(not harsh enough) ne muzic that deal wit religion... i'm ok with the death and suicide thing, but please anything but religious rock, country etc., plus i cannot put the harsh word on country... you can burn me as much as you want but i will never love country...
_______________
When you are told something for years, you learn to accept it. But, after the truth is revealed, you feel conufusion, isolation, and depression. Then you ask, where do I belong? I'm searching for that answer.

This comment was edited by Padawan On A Stick on Oct 24 2003 01:10am.

Oct 23 2003 10:28pm

Hardwired
 - Retired
 Hardwired

Not that wierd that ppl dont know about nightwish..i see that as a positive thing..

They didn't sell their soul to the god of mainstream rock.....:D
_______________
::Nothing wrong with a little shooting.....as long as the right people get shot::

Oct 23 2003 10:13pm

Fenix
 - Ex-Student
 Fenix

Evanescence rulezz ! :D
I really like them, and all their songs are great! ;)
But I havent listened to Nightwish, so i cant say something about them :D

Oct 23 2003 08:49pm

 
 - Student

Nightwish all the way!

Evanescence are for angsty teenagers that are HaRdCoRe GaWth!"!"!£$£%&$^&*%

Oct 23 2003 07:18pm

VirusD
 - Student
 VirusD

many say nightwish? GO AND LIVE UR LIFE WITH MTV AND VIVA .... damn u should listen to more then just the shit what comes from tv :P no offence >D
_______________
'** I hated going to weddings. All the grandmas would poke me saying "You're next". They stopped that when I started doing it to them at funerals.**'
'**On going to war over religion: "You're basically killing each other to see who's got the better imaginary friend.**"
'**I Dont Lie! I Just Bend And Illustrate The Truth A Little**' - By me when talking to a friend.


Oct 23 2003 06:35pm

SwordMaster
 - Ex-Student
 SwordMaster

:D:D but remember, it isnt important, who is the most famous one, but which is the better one, this is going to be close ^.^
_______________
Ride... die... sacrife!
I'm the bloody hand of tytans,
when...when demons awake!


Oct 23 2003 03:19pm

YinYang
 - Ex-Student
 YinYang

Evanescence RULES!!:D
_______________
Sister to Smily,Axion,and CT Friend to ALL... SMILY, LUKE,MAGRA,AND KOYI RULE!!!!!
. . : :There is ALWAYS 2 Yin and Yang , Good and Evil: : . .


Oct 23 2003 12:19pm

xAnAtOs
 - Student

Who the hell is nightwish? :eek:
_______________
Brother to Luke Skywalker and (SKX) Dark Blade :alliance:
Lag Brother to Acey Spadey :empire:
Jools is my best friend. :D
<Henkes> nebody feeling like abusing me with a lightsaber?|+Smilykrazy grabs Gradius, beats the living CRAP out of him, then throws him into a huge vat of ACID


Oct 23 2003 11:51am

Kueller
 - Student
 Kueller

Nightwish PWNs y00!!

Evanescense isn't bad...Nightwish is just a tad cooler! You should try After Forever too, that's a cool band!
_______________
Personal sleepness-nights-supporter of Virtue. Owner of the 1000th comment of Daidalus and 1943th comment of Gradius! Owner of the 300th comment of Carda!
-Taught Gradius all his laming skills :P


Oct 23 2003 09:28am

Flamori Athena
 - Student
 Flamori Athena

who the hell is nightwish?

wow, 3-way tie :eek:
_______________
«±» 21st on the Midbie Council, Profile ID: 2027 «±»
True wisdom is the knowledge that you know nothing.


Oct 23 2003 07:47am

Aron
 - Retired
 Aron

both suck! :p

Oct 23 2003 06:32am

MINDofSIN
 - Student
 MINDofSIN

I like both.

If I had to choose between the two, I'd listen to Bile.

:D
_______________
Jedi Academy Holocron
http://jaholocron.ryanmh.com/

Why should our government send our soldiers to foreign soil to protect freedom of speech, when our freedom of speech is being taking away everyday by the same government.


Oct 23 2003 06:07am

Cyric
 - Ex-Student
 Cyric

Never heard of nightwish, but I got a chance to see Evanescense at our local annual music festival. All I can say is that the CD doesnt even come close to reproducing the lead singers vocal range and ability. Its one of the very few bands Ive heard worth listening to in quite a while (other than Tool ofcourse - anything with Maynard is usually excellent!). :cool::cool:
_______________
"Cats always land feet down. Toast always lands butter-side down. If you strap a piece of toast to the back of a cat, it will hover above the ground in quantum indecision."-anon

Oct 22 2003 07:12pm

_cmad_
 - Ex-Student
 _cmad_

who the hell is nightwish???

btw: i don't like evanescense... not even a tiny bit ;)
_______________
Your friends of today, are your enemies of tomorrow.

Oct 22 2003 06:49pm

SwordMaster
 - Ex-Student
 SwordMaster

:D:D:D:D:DNightwish, of course !!!

yeah, anni, looks like nightwish is first, lool
(till now)

_______________
Ride... die... sacrife!
I'm the bloody hand of tytans,
when...when demons awake!


Oct 22 2003 05:55pm

Silencio
 - Student
 Silencio

What Hardwired said and a bag of chips. Evanescence isn't even comparable to Nightwish, in my opinion. Except for the fact that they have female singers, of course.. But hey, lots of bands have that these days...
_______________
Second-in-command of the mighty FiZZsters


Oct 22 2003 05:15pm

Hardwired
 - Retired
 Hardwired

I would say nightwish all the way.
In a rock aspect they are a much more solid band. And they stay nicely away from the pop gerne.

I think Eve is way to involved in a pop/rock sort of thing. They sound like alot of the basic neometal bands...but with a edge of course. The music isn't the same in sound as such. But the basic construct of their tunes are about the same. Somehow i comes out like a watered down version of similar bands.

But hey...thats just my point of view..:)
_______________
::Nothing wrong with a little shooting.....as long as the right people get shot::

Oct 22 2003 03:23pm

Bubu
 - Hubbub
 Bubu

bleh!
_______________
make install -not war

Oct 22 2003 03:17pm

VirusD
 - Student
 VirusD


Evanescence - Its a good band , but olso u can get bored of listening to their songs more then once.But stil good band .... i dont know its something rock/metal like lol.

Nightwish is symphonic metal if i am not making some mistakes here .They make longer and a little pit stronger songs then Evanescence , but still i havent heard Evanescence in live so i dont know what they are like there.

i dont like 100% studio bands they are crappy at live SO THEY ARENT REAL!!!!But well Evanescence and nightwish are diffrent from each other and i think a lot of people who watch like viva ,mtv or something like that dosent even know what nightwish really is :P .Well i think in the end : They both are good , and every porsen can listen easily to both of em. :)
_______________
'** I hated going to weddings. All the grandmas would poke me saying "You're next". They stopped that when I started doing it to them at funerals.**'
'**On going to war over religion: "You're basically killing each other to see who's got the better imaginary friend.**"
'**I Dont Lie! I Just Bend And Illustrate The Truth A Little**' - By me when talking to a friend.


< Recent Comments Login and add your comment!