The Jedi Academy. THE Place for Jedi training.
Forums
Content
The Academy
Learn
Communicate
Personal


Forums | General Discussion
A religion thread with a difference
Feb 11 2005 02:11am

Gil-Galad
 - Student
Gil-Galad
Quote:
Its not a good idea to discuss religion in a philosophical way on these forums...so i will restrain myself from answering your question.


I noticed mastas post on Jeramias thread in this forum, and he is right. But part of the reason he is right is because there isnt currently a thread for such discussion. There are threads that deal with the bible, which is a wholly different issue, and to me, an irrelevant one.

So this thread is for more general discussion of religion, in a philosophical manner. And by philosophical I mean logical, reasoned, objective arguments. Please no emotive language, and no claims which you cant or aren't willing to back up e.g. 'All religious people are stupid!', or 'God exists because the bible says so!' If you want to try and back up your arguments then fine, no claims without support. Every claim you make must be justifiable, every single sentence, every word. And above all, lets keep the tone respectful :)

So, to get the ball rolling: Religion originated as a construct of the human psyche, a defence mechanism against the harshness and mysterious nature of the reality we inhabit. For someone thousands of years ago; lightning. Today; the afterlife. This is why we see the same features in ancient gods at opposite ends of the globes, and the same fables, when there is no possible way they could travel that distance: because wherever you are from, whatever language you speak, you share the same instinctive fears of the unknown e.g. death, with everyone else. This fear was the premise of religion, and continues to be a major draw to it today, and is what has been used by those in power for thousands of years to get the masses to behave in whatever way they wish them to.

Thoughts?
_______________
|JAA| since 02/05/06

Green for life

< Recent Comments Login and add your comment! Previous Comments >
Comments
Mar 02 2005 08:52pm

Tido
 - Student
 Tido

Watching two people argue about religion is like watching two color blind men get in a bar fight about what 'green' looks like :(. Asking someone to 'prove' God's existant is completely missing the point of what faith is. Asking someone to believe in God is like asking them to leap out into nothing and telling them that the landing is there. We all have our views on the bigger picture, but what makes any one of our views any better than the other? In other words, what is the objective of arguing religion?

This comment was edited by Tido on Mar 02 2005 08:54pm.

Mar 02 2005 08:41pm

Masta
 - Jedi Council
 Masta

Quote:
And while we are at the topic of afterlife...
I would like to direct you towards a highly interesting source of information, which definately deserves at least a look.
Here we go

=D
_______________
Find out more about the Jedi Academy Aurochs here and more about Masta here!
Married to Kain.


Mar 02 2005 07:43pm

Smilykrazy
 - Retired
 Smilykrazy

Its really interesting reading everyones views. :D

The way that I am dealing with God, is I worship him and sing praise to him name. I read the bible (not as much as I would like to). And I prey. What happens after death I feel is out of my control. I feel God has a perfect plan for everyone. He knows our every thought and feeling. If I am to be Saved, then it will happen. All I can do is beg for mercy. For I know I lead a sinful life, as everyone does.

Just my thoughts. :D
_______________
RIP MOM 06/29/58-07/31/08 Married to Koyi Donita 4/30/11

Mar 02 2005 04:36pm

Gil-Galad
 - Student
 Gil-Galad

Quote:
Quote:
What does he base this decision on? Is it random? Because it seems pretty random to me, but maybe I am missing something.


The Bible tells us that before the foundations of the world, He knew us and chose those who would be redeemed as His people. He is the alfa and the omega, the beginning and the end so the start and the finish of the world are all known to Him. He knows us better then we could ever know ourselves and it is hard to say what factors came into God's choices. The Bible tells us that He isn't a respector of persons and that it's by His will that we enter into His grace so I don't think it has anything to do with how we live our lives. Seems kinda random if you look at it that way, but who truely knows other then God Himself? I'm sure it is not as random as it seems, but I don't know.


I think this highlights the difference between us Koyi. When I'm dealing with issues as huge as God, the afterlife, I refuse to deal in don't knows and probability. Which I guess is the definition of faith, you take that extra jump across the chasm of uncertainty, whereas I don't.

Quote:
Quote:
And as far as idealism goes, and that whole area of philosophy, it is not pointless, its point, just like science, is to seek a better understanding of reality, based on what we can know for sure.


Well, again. If the couch is behind me, it's behind me. Science shows and teaches me alot about this world, but I don't like it's stupid stabs into dark areas it could never know or explain. The big bang theory is rediculous in my eyes. Some of the brightest minds [even people who didn't believe in God] who have studied the universe began to believe in a creater rather then some random chaotic act forming into a perfectly balanced and well maintained universe.


I think one of the main differences between religion and science is what they count as evidence. To me, there is enormous evidence for the big bang. Firstly, the fact that all the planets and galaxies are moving away from eachother. Secondly, radiation emanating from every part of the universe, an aftermath of the big bang. Lastly, the recent discovery of uniform microwaves across the universe which demonstrate the homogenity of the early universe. There are even small fluctuations in these that support the theories ideas about the very very early stages of the universes development, in particular the rapid cooling after the initial explosion. Maybe to you, a book is better evidence, but this is where we must agree to disagree ;)

Quote:
No solid proof on evolution yet that's what we teach all the kiddies at school as if it is 100% true. We teach our children that the world is billions of billions of billions of years old, yet our very own ocean water doesn't contain enough erroded materials to back up that theory either.


An important thing to remember is that they are called theories. They claim that 'this is the best way we have of understanding whats going on at the moment'. Science stays within the evidence we have, religion does not, which is why it is dangerous to start teaching children creationism and the like, because frankly the bible is the only evidence. Whereas contrary to popularised belief, there are mountains of evidence for evolution. Of course its not 100% certain, but nor is the theory of gravity, or relativity, or any scientific theory, but remember, they arent the ones claiming that they are 100% true. Heres a very short article that refutes pretty much every criticism of evolution: http://www.geocities.com/CapeCanaveral/Lab/1366/lapointe.html. The final pont, point nine, is particularly interesting :)

Quote:
We're not trying to better understand things, we're masking them. The unknown grey areas are being colored in whether by science or religion, chose your weapon,


I disagree, religion colours them in, whereas science accepts that they are there, whilst slowly trying to unravel them.

Quote:
although we have some proof of people being moved by God and other supernatural forces.


I would be very interested in seeing this proof if we you have any access to it.

Quote:
We have ancient texts that stood the test of time being written by many different writers with a story that seems to speak in parables but has the same message from the creation story to revelation.


Egyptian heiroglyphics have also survived. The only reasons they dont have a following like christianity are historical. If egyptian mythology converted held half the known world at the point of the sword and said 'believe this or we will execute you' instead of christianity then maybe it would be the opposite way round.

Quote:
People have seen the miracles, they have witnessed Jesus and His power.


I have not, and I am yet to see any evidence of this happening.

Quote:
The Bible would have been cut off if these things weren't true, don't you think?


Not necessarily. There are excellent cultural, social, historical and psychological reasons why the bible has lasted this long.

Quote:
I could be wrong about that theory but I think if anybody in this day and age wrote a book stating thus and so and tried to make a religion out of it, it wouldn't go very far. Especially if it had prophecies past and prophecies of the future, miracles, and not one witness or solid piece of evidence backing it up. Just my thoughts on that. :)


You are right. But I dont think it would have anything to do with truth. Once again, I would point to socialogical reasons for this.

Quote:
On another note, I'm sorry too if I have said anything offensive or hurt anybody in anyway. I wasn't aiming to fight, but I do read back and see how the coals are smoking.


I'm pretty sure that was aimed at me Koyi, dont worry :D
_______________
|JAA| since 02/05/06

Green for life


This comment was edited by Gil-Galad on Mar 02 2005 04:46pm.

Mar 02 2005 03:33pm

Koyi Donita
 - Student
 Koyi Donita

Quote:
Are you comfortable with the fact that, if your God exists, then some people can suffer for the rest of eternity, but not because they didnt want to be redeemed, but because God didnt feel like it?


Yes, I am comfortable with it. Scared as hell, but I see the bigger picture in my beliefs. God is almighty God to me and whether we are created unto Him loving mercy or His wrath is His good pleasure. I know alot of great people [from the view of the world] and it saddens me greatly to know that they might not make it into God's good graces. What might seem good to one could be considered pure evil to another. That can easily be seen all around us in every day life. Buildings exploding, people dying, and on the otherside of the fence you have people high fiving and slapping buttocks. Even less intense then that is a lady driving the speed limit and someone who wants to speed slamming on their horn, speeding passed them while screaming they heads off cursing up a storm while giving them the finger. It's everywhere and we have perfect pictures to see this always in effect. Now, back to these good/great people. Just because they may seem to be fun loving, generous, beautiful people doesn't mean that in God's eyes these people are golden. Imagine them going to a church and following a bunch of false doctrines, practices, and religious ceremonies never having a true desire to seek out the Bible for all that God would want them to know or perhaps never going to church or seeking out God at all. These people in that moment decided that they would create gods for themselves to worship and follow. Their intensions may seem good in our eyes, but they are completely rebelling against God especially when God tells them that they can't buy their ways into His Grace and they believe their practices can and do save them. The message is out there in the world that a man named Jesus died, was buried, and came back from the dead to pay for the sins of His elect. Does anybody truely have an excuse when the last day comes? *sigh* Even me. As I stated earlier, I don't feel as if I'm saved as of yet or received the Holy Spirit. At any moment my life can be snuffed out and then what? I am scared that I have too much confidence that I hold truth when I can be totally blind to the true message, but I am only human and am trying my best to pass the message along. As far as God not feeling like it, no no no. I don't really agree with that. Mankind doesn't feel like it. Read the first half of the Bible and you have accounts of people with God in the midst of them rebelling over and over and over again even in the sight of plain miracles. Even in our day and age where the impossible happens and everybody is like, "Eh, could have happened." All of this creation is to God's glory from the Bible's stand point and I'm comfortable with that. If we are only here for but a handful of years, what does it matter? I'm more concerned with where we are going then where we are now.

Quote:
What does he base this decision on? Is it random? Because it seems pretty random to me, but maybe I am missing something.


The Bible tells us that before the foundations of the world, He knew us and chose those who would be redeemed as His people. He is the alfa and the omega, the beginning and the end so the start and the finish of the world are all known to Him. He knows us better then we could ever know ourselves and it is hard to say what factors came into God's choices. The Bible tells us that He isn't a respector of persons and that it's by His will that we enter into His grace so I don't think it has anything to do with how we live our lives. Seems kinda random if you look at it that way, but who truely knows other then God Himself? I'm sure it is not as random as it seems, but I don't know.

Quote:
And as far as idealism goes, and that whole area of philosophy, it is not pointless, its point, just like science, is to seek a better understanding of reality, based on what we can know for sure.


Well, again. If the couch is behind me, it's behind me. Science shows and teaches me alot about this world, but I don't like it's stupid stabs into dark areas it could never know or explain. The big bang theory is rediculous in my eyes. Some of the brightest minds [even people who didn't believe in God] who have studied the universe began to believe in a creater rather then some random chaotic act forming into a perfectly balanced and well maintained universe. No solid proof on evolution yet that's what we teach all the kiddies at school as if it is 100% true. We teach our children that the world is billions of billions of billions of years old, yet our very own ocean water doesn't contain enough erroded materials to back up that theory either. We're not trying to better understand things, we're masking them. The unknown grey areas are being colored in whether by science or religion, chose your weapon, although we have some proof of people being moved by God and other supernatural forces. We have ancient texts that stood the test of time being written by many different writers with a story that seems to speak in parables but has the same message from the creation story to revelation. I can't offer anyone any solid evidence that God is here or there, but it seems more realistic to me, that's all. People have seen the miracles, they have witnessed Jesus and His power. The Bible would have been cut off if these things weren't true, don't you think? I could be wrong about that theory but I think if anybody in this day and age wrote a book stating thus and so and tried to make a religion out of it, it wouldn't go very far. Especially if it had prophecies past and prophecies of the future, miracles, and not one witness or solid piece of evidence backing it up. Just my thoughts on that. :)



On another note, I'm sorry too if I have said anything offensive or hurt anybody in anyway. I wasn't aiming to fight, but I do read back and see how the coals are smoking.
_______________
For I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ: for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth; to the Jew first, and also to the Greek. Rom. 1:16
So then faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word of God. Rom. 10:17
I love my babyface. Smilykrazy is my baby and I love her.
...Swimming through the void we hear the Word, we lose ourselves but we find it all... System Of A Down. :D


Mar 02 2005 01:32pm

Hardwired
 - Retired
 Hardwired

Alright guys.

I was requested to have a look in this thread. And I can see where this could be going really bad. Just remember that we pride ourselves on the diversety of race and religion here. And that none of the JAK+ will stand for another flame war. Now im not saying anyone has done anything wrong...yet. This is just a preemptive strike if you will.

So..respect each others opinions and be nice about. Or so help me I will rain down fury upon you...And God ain't got nothing on me....trust me..;)

- HW
_______________
::Nothing wrong with a little shooting.....as long as the right people get shot::

Mar 02 2005 01:15pm

Gil-Galad
 - Student
 Gil-Galad

Ok sorry guys, a few swift edits are in order then :)

Edit: Done, hope thats better, sorry about that.
_______________
|JAA| since 02/05/06

Green for life


This comment was edited by Gil-Galad on Mar 02 2005 01:18pm.

Mar 02 2005 01:12pm

Gradius
 - Ex-Student
 Gradius

I agree with Masta here guys. This thread is going in the wrong direction with the last few posts. People have their beliefs and it's not our place to judge wether or not they are right or wrong. And we can't blame them for whatever they believe. Honestly, we need to either drop this thread or change the tone immediately, I do not want to see something bad happen because someone couldn't be mindful of someone elses feelings. :)
_______________
- Proud padawan of Kueller.
- We really are at the beginning of it all. The trick, of course, is to make sure we never find the end. - Bill Bryson, A Short History of Nearly Everything
- <gen-e-sis-happy> Liek, you can train, liek, a n00b, but he'll just be a trained n00b... --> Wise words!
- "daer SOE me likes your a company i am having your some money for letting me do stuff cos mes the best amd i do it all meself" - Slider


Mar 02 2005 12:06pm

Masta
 - Jedi Council
 Masta

Now now guys...lets keep it civil, shall we?
I dont wanna see this thread end up beeing some sort of holy war.

Just be thoughtful about your choice of words =)
_______________
Find out more about the Jedi Academy Aurochs here and more about Masta here!
Married to Kain.


Mar 01 2005 11:51pm

Gil-Galad
 - Student
 Gil-Galad

Quote:
Quote:
Him. Him. Him. Him. All we do is call God a man's gender because thousands of years ago, the people who made up the idea of god opressed women to an unbelievable state. If christianity believes God is omnipitant, god doesnt need to be called Him,Father,Son ect ect.


I don't know if christianity or any organized religion has or keeps the doctrine of God being omnipitant. If so, /me claps for them. Show me where it says that in the Bible and I might believe it too. I hold my beliefs from what I read from the Bible. If God presents himself as a He and establishes a chain of command, that's what I look to follow, [not practice mind you for I am not saved]. Even with the chain of command, the greatest commandment of love is still there where [in the marriage] women are to love men as they would themselves and men love women the same. In fact, God gives the example and commandment that men are to love women love women like Christ loved the Church and Christ gave His life to create His Church, [not those little or big buildings with the pretty bells mind you]. It's just in our nature to not really search out the Bible to hear it's true message driving or creating our own religion on our own beliefs and I too probably fall into this catagory. However, I am waiting and reading as carefully and prayfully as I can. It's in God's hand whether or not He will save me.

Quote:
It really does make life easier knowing you're loved all the time or your loved ones are in heaven,being loved and being happy. Parents teach their kids, the kids grow up and teach their own...thousands of years pass and we have now. The way we're brought up to think and understand things changes alot.


I agree with you whole-heartedly on this one. That is of course about all the people who have bended and twisted religion into the form that they saw fit. It is a comforting thought to think, "Wow. My afterlife is secure and my loved ones are waiting for me up in some mystical heaven when we will all remember each other and eat twinkies and dingdongs for eternity." Fact is, if you really read the Bible, most of us face damnation. Even me! I didn't come into this discussion to preach to anybody, but my points and views will still be discussed. Yes, I am currently staring down the barrel of eternity of damnation. My mother passed away very recently and my heart aches wondering if the Lord blessed her and kept her. I cry myself to sleep some nights thinking about that. It's not that we are bad people. Not in the eyes of the world have you. It's just that we don't follow all of God's commandments whole heartedly and one needs to be born again to do that. That is all God's work to do so I humbly wait for Him hoping that His grace will reach me too. Until then, I just share what I read from the Bible hoping others will open their eyes to some of the verses that can't just be ignored.

Your thoughts on upbringing has some scientific evidence supporting it and is a valid point, however I've met alot of people from the wrong side of the tracks and some of them had the most abusive lives growing up but were some of the most honest and caring people I've ever known while others were animals with no controls or limits. I think their is more to ones emotional state that just upbringing.

Idealism is nothing more then petty philosophical nonsense to me. Here I am typing and a couch lies behind me. The frickin couch is there whether or not my attention is on it in that moment and will remain there while I sleep, eat breakfast, brush my teeth, use the toilet, watch t.v., work all day, playing games, and even posting here. If someone removes it from it's place, that's a different story, but in the meantime ...It's there. Why even test the limits of thought with stuff like that? What good comes from thinking about a glass being half empty or half full?


Are you comfortable with the fact that, if your God exists, then some people can suffer for the rest of eternity, but not because they didnt want to be redeemed, but because God didnt feel like it? What does he base this decision on? Is it random? Because it seems pretty random to me, but maybeI am missing something.

And as far as idealism goes, and that whole area of philosophy, it is not pointless, its point, just like science, is to seek a better understanding of reality, based on what we can know for sure.
_______________
|JAA| since 02/05/06

Green for life


This comment was edited by Gil-Galad on Mar 02 2005 01:17pm.

Mar 01 2005 11:48pm

Scythus Aratan
 - Student
 Scythus Aratan

Quote:
God is spirit
and God IS all mighty!


Says who?

I don't believe that myself, and most likely never will.
_______________
Padawan to the great Jacen Aratan!
<Setementor> Scythus is a genius!
Claimer of the 5000th post in the Count thread [Solitude] scy rocks [Casual] good point scythus, you're really smart


Mar 01 2005 11:48pm

Gil-Galad
 - Student
 Gil-Galad

Quote:
God is spirit
and God IS all mighty!


Ok, thats your claim, now prove it.
_______________
|JAA| since 02/05/06

Green for life


Mar 01 2005 11:28pm

Jo_Mintaka
 - Student
 Jo_Mintaka

God is spirit
and God IS all mighty!

_______________
Joined Jan 27 2005
[Owner of Pink Floyd's 525th, 1100th and 4002nd comments! Darth Mike's accidental 999 and 1001 comments!
addiat's 1975 comment!


Mar 01 2005 05:04pm

Phantom
 - Student
 Phantom

Quote:
Him. Him. Him. Him. All we do is call God a man's gender because thousands of years ago, the people who made up the idea of god opressed women to an unbelievable state. If christianity believes God is omnipitant, god doesnt need to be called Him,Father,Son ect ect.


G-d is not a man, G-d is not human. We cannot understand G-d's ways. We call G-d a man because this is the best way that we can understand who He is. But in the end we really cant understand Him as a human. No one can.

*note* I am not christan, I am just explaining my own religoin.
_______________
-Phantom
Ex-Master to Threat.
Proud owner of Sazabi's 1500th comment! And Threats 50th comment
"Insanity: a perfect rational adjustment to an insane world"


Mar 01 2005 02:49pm

Koyi Donita
 - Student
 Koyi Donita

Quote:
Him. Him. Him. Him. All we do is call God a man's gender because thousands of years ago, the people who made up the idea of god opressed women to an unbelievable state. If christianity believes God is omnipitant, god doesnt need to be called Him,Father,Son ect ect.


I don't know if christianity or any organized religion has or keeps the doctrine of God being omnipitant. If so, /me claps for them. Show me where it says that in the Bible and I might believe it too. I hold my beliefs from what I read from the Bible. If God presents himself as a He and establishes a chain of command, that's what I look to follow, [not practice mind you for I am not saved]. Even with the chain of command, the greatest commandment of love is still there where [in the marriage] women are to love men as they would themselves and men love women the same. In fact, God gives the example and commandment that men are to love women love women like Christ loved the Church and Christ gave His life to create His Church, [not those little or big buildings with the pretty bells mind you]. It's just in our nature to not really search out the Bible to hear it's true message driving or creating our own religion on our own beliefs and I too probably fall into this catagory. However, I am waiting and reading as carefully and prayfully as I can. It's in God's hand whether or not He will save me.

Quote:
It really does make life easier knowing you're loved all the time or your loved ones are in heaven,being loved and being happy. Parents teach their kids, the kids grow up and teach their own...thousands of years pass and we have now. The way we're brought up to think and understand things changes alot.


I agree with you whole-heartedly on this one. That is of course about all the people who have bended and twisted religion into the form that they saw fit. It is a comforting thought to think, "Wow. My afterlife is secure and my loved ones are waiting for me up in some mystical heaven when we will all remember each other and eat twinkies and dingdongs for eternity." Fact is, if you really read the Bible, most of us face damnation. Even me! I didn't come into this discussion to preach to anybody, but my points and views will still be discussed. Yes, I am currently staring down the barrel of eternity of damnation. My mother passed away very recently and my heart aches wondering if the Lord blessed her and kept her. I cry myself to sleep some nights thinking about that. It's not that we are bad people. Not in the eyes of the world have you. It's just that we don't follow all of God's commandments whole heartedly and one needs to be born again to do that. That is all God's work to do so I humbly wait for Him hoping that His grace will reach me too. Until then, I just share what I read from the Bible hoping others will open their eyes to some of the verses that can't just be ignored.

Your thoughts on upbringing has some scientific evidence supporting it and is a valid point, however I've met alot of people from the wrong side of the tracks and some of them had the most abusive lives growing up but were some of the most honest and caring people I've ever known while others were animals with no controls or limits. I think their is more to ones emotional state that just upbringing.

Idealism is nothing more then petty philosophical nonsense to me. Here I am typing and a couch lies behind me. The frickin couch is there whether or not my attention is on it in that moment and will remain there while I sleep, eat breakfast, brush my teeth, use the toilet, watch t.v., work all day, playing games, and even posting here. If someone removes it from it's place, that's a different story, but in the meantime ...It's there. Why even test the limits of thought with stuff like that? What good comes from thinking about a glass being half empty or half full?
_______________
For I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ: for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth; to the Jew first, and also to the Greek. Rom. 1:16
So then faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word of God. Rom. 10:17
I love my babyface. Smilykrazy is my baby and I love her.
...Swimming through the void we hear the Word, we lose ourselves but we find it all... System Of A Down. :D


Mar 01 2005 01:26am

Plo Koon
 - Student
 Plo Koon

Quote:
The problem (the way I see it) is that mankind has become god in their own minds. We build, we create, we sustain, and we even go as far as to think God should be thus and so. Imagine making a plate or a cup or a pot and when finishing your work the item you just made starts questioning "Why did you make me thus and so?" Did you not want to make a plate or cup or pot for whatever purpose you saw fit?

God is God. You can deny Him, turn away from Him, or just totally believe that He doesn't exist because He doesn't fit into your perfect cookie cutting patterns that you believe He should follow after. I'll respond in greater detail after I've read the last few posts a little later.



Him. Him. Him. Him. All we do is call God a man's gender because thousands of years ago, the people who made up the idea of god opressed women to an unbelievable state. If christianity believes God is omnipitant, god doesnt need to be called Him,Father,Son ect ect.

It really does make life easier knowing you're loved all the time or your loved ones are in heaven,being loved and being happy. Parents teach their kids, the kids grow up and teach their own...thousands of years pass and we have now. The way we're brought up to think and understand things changes alot.
_______________
Free Tibet!
Click this link,and learn
Here too


Feb 28 2005 04:45pm

Gil-Galad
 - Student
 Gil-Galad

Quote:
Fact - If there is a God who created, maintains, and will destroy this universe then God exists whether or not if anybody believes in Him.


The point is that he didn't create us, we created him, just like we created Barney the Dinosaur or Mickey Mouse. The existence of God is purely the result of human fears of the unknown. Also in prehistoric times, a means of controlling society was needed, and the patriarchs of those early societies realised that this product of their fears was an excellent means for control and order that would allow them to advance beyond barbarism. Without a doubt the creation of God was the single biggest factor in civilizing humanity, but only because it provided an effective means of control that was lacking previously.

Quote:
In fact, the Bible tells us that not one of us is righteous or seeks after Him until He draws that person to Himself.


Prove to me that the bible is really the word of God, then we can start using it as evidence. Otherwise, I could just start citing Lord Of The Rings or anything I wanted.

Quote:
What I just quoted from what you had said reminds me of something I heard a long time ago. If a tree falls in the forest but nobody is around to hear it come crashing down, did the tree fall? Well, of course it did because it fell. No witnesses are needed in order for the event to take place.


You misunderstand the point. This question comes from a theory called 'Idealism'. What its saying is that if noone saw it fall, then you dont know that it did so. What its illustrating is that if you cant see something, you have no way of knowing it exists. For example, right now I'm facing away from my bed. Im not touching it, I cant see it. Therefore I dont know that it still exists.

Another point of discussion I've been thinking about. Why Christianity/Islam/Judaism? What makes someone believe in one and not the other? None of them are more valid and coherent than the others. There is just as much or little proof for all of them. So why choose to be a Christian for example, and not a muslim, considering that there is no logical reason to call one more true than any other?
_______________
|JAA| since 02/05/06

Green for life


Feb 28 2005 03:44pm

Koyi Donita
 - Student
 Koyi Donita

Quote:
If the christian God had no followers, he would have no influnce on the world.


Fact - If there is a God who created, maintains, and will destroy this universe then God exists whether or not if anybody believes in Him. In fact, the Bible tells us that not one of us is righteous or seeks after Him until He draws that person to Himself.

What I just quoted from what you had said reminds me of something I heard a long time ago. If a tree falls in the forest but nobody is around to hear it come crashing down, did the tree fall? Well, of course it did because it fell. No witnesses are needed in order for the event to take place.

Oh, and one other question if I may. I'm sure alot of us know that everyday drinking water has minerals and such in it. Why is that? How does that happen? Do we dump minerals into our water so it sells water filtration systems? No. Fact is that water is the universal solvent and errodes rocks and earth away carrying the errosion in it. Now if the earth is billions of billions of billions of years old, why is it that not one element is found to be a supersaturated solution within the oceans? Fact is that our oceans don't have as much minerals as we would think being carried from all the streams and rivers of the world. Just phood for thought and conversation. ;)
_______________
For I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ: for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth; to the Jew first, and also to the Greek. Rom. 1:16
So then faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word of God. Rom. 10:17
I love my babyface. Smilykrazy is my baby and I love her.
...Swimming through the void we hear the Word, we lose ourselves but we find it all... System Of A Down. :D


Feb 26 2005 04:02pm

Scythus Aratan
 - Student
 Scythus Aratan

Quote:

God is God. You can deny Him, turn away from Him, or just totally believe that He doesn't exist because He doesn't fit into your perfect cookie cutting patterns that you believe He should follow after.


But the fact is that people do. I'm doing it right now. If God does exist, then he hasn't done a whole lot in the past thousand years. A God is created by it's followers. If the christian God had no followers, he would have no influnce on the world.
_______________
Padawan to the great Jacen Aratan!
<Setementor> Scythus is a genius!
Claimer of the 5000th post in the Count thread [Solitude] scy rocks [Casual] good point scythus, you're really smart


Feb 26 2005 02:48pm

Koyi Donita
 - Student
 Koyi Donita

The problem (the way I see it) is that mankind has become god in their own minds. We build, we create, we sustain, and we even go as far as to think God should be thus and so. Imagine making a plate or a cup or a pot and when finishing your work the item you just made starts questioning "Why did you make me thus and so?" Did you not want to make a plate or cup or pot for whatever purpose you saw fit?

God is God. You can deny Him, turn away from Him, or just totally believe that He doesn't exist because He doesn't fit into your perfect cookie cutting patterns that you believe He should follow after. I'll respond in greater detail after I've read the last few posts a little later.
_______________
For I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ: for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth; to the Jew first, and also to the Greek. Rom. 1:16
So then faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word of God. Rom. 10:17
I love my babyface. Smilykrazy is my baby and I love her.
...Swimming through the void we hear the Word, we lose ourselves but we find it all... System Of A Down. :D


Feb 24 2005 08:31pm

Gil-Galad
 - Student
 Gil-Galad

Quote:
I agree with you totally. I'd rather not believe in a god...than a god that just sits by and lets the Haulocost, WWI, WW2, Sudan, vietnam, The Congo and the millions upon millions of un-needed deaths that go by each day happen.


I agree. I dont buy all the 'its not our place to question' stuff, because if thats the kind of thing God lets happen, without feeling the need to tell us why, I've got better things to do then worship His arrogant ass even if he does exist.
_______________
|JAA| since 02/05/06

Green for life


Feb 24 2005 07:47pm

Plo Koon
 - Student
 Plo Koon

Quote:
Okay... so this thread got quite unphilosophical quite quickly. Let me try something different.

Firstly in response to people who say that our human logic is incapable of understanding god etc, so whatever we say or think is pointless. People have used this kind of excuse for millenia for many different things. 'Oh no, my husband knows best, he can beat me, I won't question it'. 'Oh no, the King/Government knows best, I'll send my son to be killed at war, I won't question it'. 'Oh no, God lets a tsunami kill 200,000 people, but I wont question it'. Its a copout, and a sign that your fear of thinking for yourself and the conclusions you might come to, is greater than your fear of the consequences of not doing so. Questioning authority and logically examining beliefs is the only way humanity will ever reach any form of enlightenment.

If we had never questioned God or the bible, imagine how homosexuals would be treated. It is because we have our logic, and do question authority that we can realise things such as 'actually, gay people are no different really, there is nothing 'evil' about them, they're just attracted to the same sex, wheres the harm in that?'. We would also have no contraception, would wear no man made fibers, would think masturbation a sin, and the immense suffering caused by christianity throughout the ages would be rampaging. It is only people questioning the people in authority, thinking for themselves, and questioning the bible throughout history that have prevented this state of affairs, and let us evolve into a society that has so many more freedoms than it used to.

This progress will never be stopped, although it will always be slow. Wherever there are people questioning authority, preventing progress, there are those that will stand in the way. They always lose, but it takes a long time. Our logic and questioning of authority has brought down many authorities throughout history, and has brought down many freedom constricting institutions.

In my opinion, in the last few centuries, a revolution has started due to the spread of freedom of speech, across the globe, and eventually it will bring down and kill forever the greatest authority and myth created by man, God himself. Only then, when this cloak of mysticism and fantasy has been stripped away will we see the world for what it is, begin to understand it better, and then we can start to right the wrongs in our society, on the basis of logic and morality. Those who have used God to disguise their prejudices will be stripped bare, and forced to confront themselves and their fears. Those for whom religion was merely a complex comfort blanket will see the world for the first time. Those who used religion as a motive for aggression, and a means to fulfil their greed will be exposed, and will no longer be able to use 'good' and 'evil' to divide the world into black and white, or to use their religion to fool people into seeing it the same way. And people who perform kind acts will do so because they care about people, just because they are people, not because of any reward/punishment system in the afterlife. Things will still of course be far from perfect, but we will start to see things clearer, when the shrowd of mysticism is pulled back and the harsh light of reality lays our follies bare before us. Only by questioning authority, no matter who or what it is, and using our limited logic will be ever bring about these changes.

If people want to opt out, to have blind faith, thats their choice, but I for one will use my mind, my plodding and limited logic, to the best of my ability, because in the end, only good can come of it, and i encourage everyone else to do the same.

Secondly, I noticed a little about the problem of evil and the free will defence in the bible study thread. Not wanting to hijack the thread, I'll ask the question here; what if I dont want free will? Putting aside the fact I don't think there are any logical grounds whatsoever for believing we have free will, what if i said to God 'yeah thanks and all that, this free will thingy is very nice, but tbh I'm fairly fed up of seeing starving people on my TV screen everyday, of children being beaten and wives being raped, and men killing eachother, so thanks, but no thanks'? Anyones thoughts?



I agree with you totally. I'd rather not believe in a god...than a god that just sits by and lets the Haulocost, WWI, WW2, Sudan, vietnam, The Congo and the millions upon millions of un-needed deaths that go by each day happen.
_______________
Free Tibet!
Click this link,and learn
Here too


Feb 24 2005 06:01pm

Masta
 - Jedi Council
 Masta

Well, i couldnt agree more on the first part.

Asking about "what would happen if we could reject free will" is gonna move this discussion into the infinite world of "if"´s and "maybe"´s.But hey, sure...heres what i think would happen if the whole humanity would reject free will and replace it with Gods judgement.
I guess the world would be erm...a lot better, due to the fact that God (as stated by christianity) has lightside mastery which gives him a +20 bonus to Love and Careness...which would free the world of all harm and evil.Humanity would most likely live in some sort of paradise...and the only loss would be the illusion of making your own choices.We would just let God choose every step and move for us and focus a lot more on enjoying life instead of making choices.
It would be quite an interesting image...having stripped away the illusions once and for all.Especially because they would be replaced with Gods will, and since God doesnt want anyone to get harmed, we would be living in a paradise.
_______________
Find out more about the Jedi Academy Aurochs here and more about Masta here!
Married to Kain.


This comment was edited by Masta on Feb 24 2005 06:03pm.

Feb 22 2005 11:20pm

Gil-Galad
 - Student
 Gil-Galad

Okay... so this thread got quite unphilosophical quite quickly. Let me try something different.

Firstly in response to people who say that our human logic is incapable of understanding god etc, so whatever we say or think is pointless. People have used this kind of excuse for millenia for many different things. 'Oh no, my husband knows best, he can beat me, I won't question it'. 'Oh no, the King/Government knows best, I'll send my son to be killed at war, I won't question it'. 'Oh no, God lets a tsunami kill 200,000 people, but I wont question it'. Its a copout, and a sign that your fear of thinking for yourself and the conclusions you might come to, is greater than your fear of the consequences of not doing so. Questioning authority and logically examining beliefs is the only way humanity will ever reach any form of enlightenment.

If we had never questioned God or the bible, imagine how homosexuals would be treated. It is because we have our logic, and do question authority that we can realise things such as 'actually, gay people are no different really, there is nothing 'evil' about them, they're just attracted to the same sex, wheres the harm in that?'. We would also have no contraception, would wear no man made fibers, would think masturbation a sin, and the immense suffering caused by christianity throughout the ages would be rampaging. It is only people questioning the people in authority, thinking for themselves, and questioning the bible throughout history that have prevented this state of affairs, and let us evolve into a society that has so many more freedoms than it used to.

This progress will never be stopped, although it will always be slow. Wherever there are people questioning authority, preventing progress, there are those that will stand in the way. They always lose, but it takes a long time. Our logic and questioning of authority has brought down many authorities throughout history, and has brought down many freedom constricting institutions.

In my opinion, in the last few centuries, a revolution has started due to the spread of freedom of speech, across the globe, and eventually it will bring down and kill forever the greatest authority and myth created by man, God himself. Only then, when this cloak of mysticism and fantasy has been stripped away will we see the world for what it is, begin to understand it better, and then we can start to right the wrongs in our society, on the basis of logic and morality. Those who have used God to disguise their prejudices will be stripped bare, and forced to confront themselves and their fears. Those for whom religion was merely a complex comfort blanket will see the world for the first time. Those who used religion as a motive for aggression, and a means to fulfil their greed will be exposed, and will no longer be able to use 'good' and 'evil' to divide the world into black and white, or to use their religion to fool people into seeing it the same way. And people who perform kind acts will do so because they care about people, just because they are people, not because of any reward/punishment system in the afterlife. Things will still of course be far from perfect, but we will start to see things clearer, when the shrowd of mysticism is pulled back and the harsh light of reality lays our follies bare before us. Only by questioning authority, no matter who or what it is, and using our limited logic will be ever bring about these changes.

If people want to opt out, to have blind faith, thats their choice, but I for one will use my mind, my plodding and limited logic, to the best of my ability, because in the end, only good can come of it, and i encourage everyone else to do the same.

Secondly, I noticed a little about the problem of evil and the free will defence in the bible study thread. Not wanting to hijack the thread, I'll ask the question here; what if I dont want free will? Putting aside the fact I don't think there are any logical grounds whatsoever for believing we have free will, what if i said to God 'yeah thanks and all that, this free will thingy is very nice, but tbh I'm fairly fed up of seeing starving people on my TV screen everyday, of children being beaten and wives being raped, and men killing eachother, so thanks, but no thanks'? Anyones thoughts?
_______________
|JAA| since 02/05/06

Green for life


This comment was edited by Gil-Galad on Feb 24 2005 04:51pm.

Feb 17 2005 12:06am

tarpman
 - The Tarped Avenger
 tarpman

With respect to Koyi's most recent comment, while I personally stand for complete equality (none of this women's rights BS, just straight up equality), that system quite possibly could resolve a fair number of domestic disagreements in advance.

However, the Bible, like everything else, should be taken with a grain of salt (not as "gospel truth", pun intended :P). Even if the disciples themselves weren't, the people who were literate enough to write down their words were probably crusty old men who had no time for women at all.
_______________
Saving the world, one kilobyte at a time.

< Recent Comments Login and add your comment! Previous Comments >