Quote:


But remember, wasnt count dooku meant to be the greatest saberist ever in his young days? Surely in his 'older' age (which he was in ep.2&3) he still had some of that original class still with him and in his younger age, he would have been a more than equal match for the great Mace windu! After all....it mainly took three of them in episode 2, Obiwan and Anakin getting injured rather badly and even yoda couldnt defeat him, although he did weaken him rather substantially!

Come to think of it, i agree with you on your point which u made about Obiwan Being the best of his form but i think that he would have been able to defeat yoda, if he for some strange scenario, had to face him...Obiwan shows that sheer determination, something which he showed more then ANY of the other characters (apart from Luke Skywalker, who wouldnt give in to the dark side) in Episode 1, where he was cornered by, not a superior saberist, but by one who took advantage of the surroundings around him....(Darth Maul!!!!)...Maul not only managed to keep both obi and qui-gon at bay but he had the advantage of those timed sheild things which helped spark Obiwan's determination when he saw his master getting defeated by Darth Maul. Even as Obiwan lost his saber, his pure determination and you could say 'anger' at his masters death helped him think it wasnt over and that he wasnt going to die/lose this epic duel so he grabbed his masters saber and completely outclassed what Maul was thinking (Maul underestimated him there for a second which lead to his downfall)


Ive gone completely off the subject but the hell with that lol

Ok...my mind is changing as i cant argue with what u said about Obiwan being the best saberist but i instead agree with u on your thought of him being the greatest saberist of his 'form'.


Ok, i think Mace Windu is the greatest saberist of all time. He was elegant, Calm, showed little or no emotion it seemed, was a good talker too and most importantly, he could duel and duel well! If i remember, Cheshire Cat once told me that it would basically be impossible on a one on one duel between Mace Windu and another jedi/sith for Windu to be defeated because his style is just too good, cant really remember but i wouldnt mind it if Cheshire had a word in on this if u could please


Whoa....i havent answered the question at all...ive just confused myself and you probably lol! Hope you can understand what im saying

Quote:


Obi-Wan was a VERY skilled Saberist, and probably the greatest in his Form, but I'm pretty sure he couldn't have beated Yoda, Mace Winu or the Emperor, seeing as he was pretty much owned by Count Dooku who was weaker than the ones in the Poll.

Yeah Anakin Solo is definitly one of my fav's. It sucks that he has to die. Mara Jade Skywalker said that if he survived the YV invasion he would be the most poerful Jedi of his generation. Even at 17 years old, the time of his death He was extremely powerful in the force.

Think of a Sith dueling with furious anger. It is said that some of the old sith lords actually has lightning coming off of their bodies.
In Anakins last battle (where he died) He was so in tune with the Light side that his skin actually glowed. I think he would have surpassed the level of alot of the old masters.

Anakin was going to be a great character and jedi, his death worked well but its shame because he would of probably been my favourite if he had stayed alive, had loads of potential

Jaina Solo is pretty cool, she has a sexeh purple saber as well.

Well here is what I reckon, Luke Skywalker after the yuuzhan vong wars was certainly amazingly skilled with his saber and more importantly the force however he didnt have much in the way of a saber using oppenent in this era, the yuuzhan vong amphistaffs couldnt really be anything like a saber so pitting everybody mentioned at the peak of their powers with no force (although it is silly to say that because in-game it affects jump etc but in RL (well kinda) it helped concentration and accuracy also) I really dont know who would come out on top but I dont think Mace Windu although being ridiculously cool would get to the top.

And I couldn't find the previous post about this subject Mastz00r.

What's up with the guy you mentioned? Never seen him before. Do you mean he's a great dueller in JKJA? Or where you kidding around?

Quote:


yeah but you have to take into consideration that at the beginning of that fight the Emperor took out 3 Jedi Masters with 5 swings(im pretty sure). and then bam at the end is laying on the floor with a Purple saber right in his face... that right there IMO shows just how Good Windu(my fav SW character BTW) is. now im just stating my opinion of course..