The Jedi Academy. THE Place for Jedi training.
Forums
Content
The Academy
Learn
Communicate
Personal


Forums | Star Wars Discussion
Dark VS Light Side of the Force
May 30 2003 07:51pm

_cmad_
 - ex-Student
_cmad_
Okay about time I edited this thread after 1/2 year of life.

Can you imagine SW if there was only the Dark or the Light side??? It would *definitely* _STINK_!
However, which is more powerful? I think it's the Dark Side:

=> More Jedi fall to the d/s than Sith/Dark Jedi go to the l/s (MANY more)

=> Look at the duels (in the movies). You see the Sith being calm (prolly fighting more than one Jedi) and the Jedi being ready to shit on themselves :P

=> The d/s force powers are offensive (used to kill :cool: ) whereas the l/s force powers are defensive. And we all know the best defense is offense ;)

=> NORMALLY, when some Jedi fights a Sith the Sith has the Force Power advantage. Not many Jedi can absorb D/S Force Powers. They must be really trained, and that's unusual. OK Yoda is the force beast (I mean he handles the force like no-one else can, hmm, maybe like Palpatine, just maybe, but prolly a bit more) so he was really cool defending against Dooku's force powers. But, see, Dooku was less trained than Yoda in the Force and still he could attack him alright without losing (lightsaber fight is something else, not concerning the Force Sides). So as you can see less trained D/Sers can beat the hell outta a Jedi using the force alone :D :P (don't include Yoda eh)

=> And well, after seeing the movies, haven't you noticed how much cooler the Sith are than the Jedi? :)


******BTW: Who wants to see a Yoda VS Palpatine fight on ep3!!!???******
_______________
Your friends of today, are your enemies of tomorrow.

This post was edited by _cmad_ on Jan 10 2004 09:49am.

Poll
Which is more powerful? :

vote results

< Recent Comments Login and add your comment! Previous Comments >
Comments
Jul 26 2003 09:33pm

Iceman - away-
 - Student

And that thing score board cmad ur wrong on one thing. obi wan weren't defeated he became one with the force. And remember when Luke asked Obi1 if the dark side is stronger? Obi said that its not. Jedis aren't weak I think dark siders are. Like Dooku he couldn't resist going to the dark side. And Anakin sure he was the one but he was filled with anger. And he needed Palpy as a second master to make it so far. And go under the service of Palpatine.

This comment was edited by Iceman - away- on Jul 26 2003 10:46pm.

Jul 26 2003 08:22am

_cmad_
 - Ex-Student
 _cmad_

they're not weird Jacen... they're cowards! :P lmao!
_______________
Your friends of today, are your enemies of tomorrow.

Jul 25 2003 09:22pm

Jacen Aratan
 - Student

Yeah.... they're weird those Jedi's.

Jul 25 2003 08:06pm

Carve
 - Student
 Carve

Word, Flash.
_______________
©

Jul 25 2003 06:42pm

Flash
 - Student
 Flash

"- Last, it was the Sith who were emperors and took over the galaxy, not the Jedi!!!"

The Jedi could've taken over the galaxy, there were alot more of them, but the Jedi are peaceful, they don't want to rule the galaxy.

Jul 25 2003 03:04pm

_cmad_
 - Ex-Student
 _cmad_

bah!!! i was "young and naive" (copyright Palpatine) then.. :D

in programming forums if for example someone creates a thread in the C++ forum that says that "Java is DEFINITELY better than C++", it is guaranteed that u have at least 30 posts a day... seriously.. check it out for urself! ;)
_______________
Your friends of today, are your enemies of tomorrow.

Jul 25 2003 11:28am

Flamori Athena
 - Student
 Flamori Athena

"I predict a huge fights of opinions right now. I guess there will be more than 100 post before 7 days pass ;) Or not :( Don't let me down..."
_______________
«±» 21st on the Midbie Council, Profile ID: 2027 «±»
True wisdom is the knowledge that you know nothing.


Jul 25 2003 11:20am

_cmad_
 - Ex-Student
 _cmad_

wtf?? what d'u mean flamori?? :confused:
_______________
Your friends of today, are your enemies of tomorrow.

Jul 25 2003 11:14am

Flamori Athena
 - Student
 Flamori Athena

well cmad, that's two months and only 41 posts..:P
_______________
«±» 21st on the Midbie Council, Profile ID: 2027 «±»
True wisdom is the knowledge that you know nothing.


Jul 25 2003 06:53am

_cmad_
 - Ex-Student
 _cmad_

u forgot to mention many l/s jedi against u (a d/s jedi)... u would also staind a chance.

anyway, that line i said ("to know the light u must see the dark";) is wise :cool: because one does not know the peace and all the other stuff the l/s provides, if he doesn't know how the evil and full of lies the d/s is.

too bad i am DEEPLY put into the d/s and i can't return. so the d/s shall prevail!!! :empire: here we go again! lol. I am a quite a bit more evil than Vader. Deep (VERY VERY deep) inside me i am good and polite. However, my character is evil and i am full of lies (Jacen can prove that :D).

Maybe i am like palpatine... no return... no start.

also i think the following is wise: "To know the dark u must see the light". Coz if u haven't seen the l/s u can't see how powerful the force abilities in the d/s are (they r all offensive).

:)
_______________
Your friends of today, are your enemies of tomorrow.

Jul 24 2003 11:33pm

Carve
 - Student
 Carve

Entirely true. Observe the styles of fighting between the lightside Jedi and the darkside Jedi. You can clearly see that one is based on skill and finesse, the other on strength and power. These are -different- ways of dueling; neither is superior nor inferior. Applying this to Jedi Outcast; If I were fighting several Dark Jedi and I was a Dark Jedi myself, I would likely get my ass whupped. If I were fighting several Dark Jedi and I was a Lightside Jedi, I would stand a fighting chance. It's all about perspective; there is no 'better' or 'stronger' Force.
_______________
©

Jul 24 2003 09:41pm

_cmad_
 - Ex-Student
 _cmad_

i guess i must agree... also, check what the JK2 CD cover says in the back:

"To know the light, you must see the dark" :cool:
_______________
Your friends of today, are your enemies of tomorrow.

Jul 24 2003 08:44pm

Burn
 - Ex-Student
 Burn

Further more,
Think of it all this way (in reguards to which side is better)
In the universe There is positive and negative.
With out light there would be no dark. Because there would be nothing to distinguish darkness.
With out darkness, there would be no light, it would just be there. They need to both exsist for even one to exsist.
-Burn:alliance:
_______________
-Has no family, nor "friends"
-What is this "friends" you speak of? No not the meaning of it do I


Jul 24 2003 08:39pm

Burn
 - Ex-Student
 Burn

From reading books,
if i remember correctly;
The sith were an actual race of non humans. When Dark Jedi, discovered there long forgotten teachings. Thus adapting them and began to train as what would be known as sith lords. If you read the Thrawn Trilogy you will take notice to master Ce'Broeth or something like that, now, he uses lightning, clearly a darkside matter. However, he is not of the sith. He is merely a dark jedi. (or as i saw it a Jedi who just went crazy)
-Burn:alliance:
_______________
-Has no family, nor "friends"
-What is this "friends" you speak of? No not the meaning of it do I


Jul 24 2003 05:06pm

Virtue
 - Jedi Council
 Virtue

I'll back Flash and cM@D there.
Sith are trained differently.
Whilst Dark Jedi are simply Jedi Knights who fell to the Dark Side.

- Virty. :alliance:
_______________
Academy Architect

Jul 24 2003 08:45am

_cmad_
 - Ex-Student
 _cmad_

no m8... flash is right! Sith ARE different from the Dark Jedi. :)
_______________
Your friends of today, are your enemies of tomorrow.

Jul 23 2003 07:56pm

Newtius Slasher
 - Ex-Student
 Newtius Slasher

Dark Jedi Are sith. the term sith is no longer used to Describe the Sith Race it used to describe the Dark Jedi
:alliance::empire:

Jul 23 2003 12:51pm

Flash
 - Student
 Flash

I think you guys are mixing up the Sith/Dark Jedi thing. After Episode VI, the Sith were extinct. Then there were only Jedi who fell to the Dark Side, becoming Dark Jedi, not Sith. And Dark Jedi aren't limited to pairs.:)

Jul 22 2003 09:12am

_cmad_
 - Ex-Student
 _cmad_

i also think the same goes for Maul and Obiwan... Just that Maul was surprised from the jump. If only Maul had an average IQ, and not a negative, he would have beaten ObiWan as well!!! His face was like :S when he saw ObiWan jumping above him!!! grrrrrr :mad:
_______________
Your friends of today, are your enemies of tomorrow.

Jul 22 2003 03:02am

Eeth Koth
 - Student
 Eeth Koth

It depends on your outlook on the Force, I would imagine. If you are talking about it in a strict martial sense, yes the darkside would be stronger, as the lightside doesn't incorporate offensive moves with use of the Force. The extent they really go with it is a force push.

In terms of raw power, I don't believe either side is stronger so to speak. They are just focused differently, light side with more passive moves and such, and dark more aggressive based.

If they had a contest to see who could meditate the longest, im sure the light siders would win hehe.

The fights with lightsabers aren't really a tribute to dark or light side ability. Someones fighting ability is generally the deciding factor, although the Force does play a part there. I have no doubts that Dooku would have defeated both obiwan and anakin even without use of the darkside, he was simply a better saberist. Same goes for Maul against Quigon.

Jul 20 2003 09:22pm

Master Wallwalker
 - Ex-Student

I could smack some of you.

Why? I'll tell you.

Luke was too enraged when he smoked Vader. Watch the movie and look at his face as he hacks off Vader's hand.

Second, the Sith only do the Master/Apprentice thing because of one thing: The Great Sith War. There used to be thousands of Sith, but they turned on each other and slaughtered themselves. Thereafter, it was decided that there would only be two, in order to hide the Sith from the Jedi until it was time to take over.

Dark Side is the way to be. Now stop denying it before I choke you! :empire:
_______________
May the Force be with you. Well, sometimes. Perhaps on Tuesdays and Thursdays.

Jul 20 2003 05:47pm

Virtue
 - Jedi Council
 Virtue

Luke Beat Vader when he was enraged. But can you prove that he woudn't have beat him anyway?
He wasn't losing to Vader when they were fighting.
If fact, he got one over on Vader by kicking him down a staircase.
It would be wrong to assume that Luke beat Vader because he was enraged (thus using the Dark Side). You might say that he beat him FASTER than he would normally have BECAUSE of the Dark side. Which is what the Dark side is all about - The Faster Way to do it.

People do not fear the Light Siders because they are there to protect. Why fear something that is there to help you?

You will never see a Light Sider taking over the Galaxy because the Light side is there to protect it, not pWn it.

The reason Dark Siders look calm in Battle is because they THINK that their power is far superior to his/her opponents. Why fear something that you beleive to be less powerfull than you?
Whereas the Light Siders just fight naturally.

People turn to the Dark side for VERY different reasons...
Most of them are mere Padawans who have not learned the passive, patient ways of the Jedi, and therefore feel they need to advance faster.
Or the Temptation of Power lures them across.

Others do it to benefit others without realising it's lure.
Take Dooku for example. He was a Jedi Master before he turned, not a Padawan. He felt that the use of the Dark Side would benefit his peers and help defeat the orders opposers in a faster manner. But the sheer temptation of the Darkside's promise of Ultimate power eventually lured him to use it for his own selfish ends and therefore he became the Dark and Evil man that he was.
In the EU, Luke Skywalker turned to the Dark Side because he felt that by doing so, he could Liquidate it from the inside, rather than directly fighting it as a Jedi. But, like Dooku, he fell to it's temptations. But was eventually turned back to the Light by Mara Jade.

In conclusion.
There is no "Stronger" side to the Force. It's pretty much an equal balance between Light and Dark. For every Dark Ability, there is a Light ability that can nullify it (Yoda and Obi-Wan Absorbing Dooku's Lightning attacks). And vice-versa. The only reason so many people THINK the Dark Side is more powerfull is because of its Physical attacks.
Whereas the Light Side focusses on Meditation, Peace and Skill. Which combined can conjour masses of strength and skill over a period of time. As this is not physically apparant, like the use of Lightning to fry an opponent. People see that Dark Side as much more powerfull, when this is simply not the case.

- Virtue. :alliance:
_______________
Academy Architect

Jul 18 2003 03:42pm

_cmad_
 - Ex-Student
 _cmad_

Lucas's a wise man... I can prove that; he invented Star Wars :D
_______________
Your friends of today, are your enemies of tomorrow.

Jul 17 2003 03:42pm

cHoSeN oNe
 - Retired
 cHoSeN oNe

If you know both, then you are more powerful. Lucas said that the greed for more power, will be to go over to the darkside because it is more powerful.
_______________
Get busy living, or get busy dying.

Jul 09 2003 09:34pm

Kueller
 - Student
 Kueller

This is very good indeed. You catch the meaning of the force well. Nice to have another movie-knower amongst us.
*reaches out to hand a clubpass*
_______________
Personal sleepness-nights-supporter of Virtue. Owner of the 1000th comment of Daidalus and 1943th comment of Gradius! Owner of the 300th comment of Carda!
-Taught Gradius all his laming skills :P


< Recent Comments Login and add your comment! Previous Comments >